No Spread Gluten-Free Sugar Cookie Recipe

This gluten-free sugar cookie recipe is sponsored by Bob’s Red Mill and contains affiliate links. The post was last updated on November 19, 2019 with new pictures and baking instructions. Please see my disclosures for details.

I keep getting requests for a gluten-free sugar cookie recipe, so I decided this year would be the year I would create one… actually, this is the year I would PERFECT a gluten-free sugar cookie recipe. Yes indeed, these cookies are PERFECT in taste and texture.

Of course there are a ton of gluten-free sugar cookie recipes widely available on the Internet, and I’ve tried a lot of them.

Honestly, none of them wowed me. Some were too crunchy and grainy. Some recipes even failed miserably because the cookies spread and didn’t keep their shape as promised.

Having no luck on the Internet, I tried to create a recipe of my own using a variety of gluten-free flours. Some turned out okay … but in all honesty, the ones that turned out the BEST were made with my trusty Bob’s Red Mill 1-to-1 Gluten-Free Flour Blend.

This 1:1 gluten-free flour blend works like a charm each and every time I use it.

Recipe Inspiration

The inspiration for this no-spread gluten-free sugar cookie recipe came from the book, Ratio by Michael Ruhlman.

Ruhlman is a baker who has decoded the secrets to baking to specific ratios or combinations of fat, flour and sugar.

Ruhlman’s sugar cookie ratio calls for equal parts sugar and fat (so 8 ounces of butter and 8 ounces of sugar) along with an egg and 1.5 parts flour (or 50 percent more flour). It gets a little confusing to a novice baker like me, but Ruhlman explains all the science in his book and I’m willing to just go with it!

With this knowledge, I decided to create my own gluten-free sugar cookie recipe using the Bob’s Red Mill 1-to-1 Gluten-Free Flour Blend and the ratios set forth by Ruhlman. I have found that Bob’s Red Mill 1-to-1 Gluten-Free Flour Blend can be used in most recipes as a cup for cup substitute for wheat flour. Bob’s makes gluten-free baking so easy to do and you can convert just about any recipe that calls for wheat flour into a gluten-free masterpiece.

After playing with the ratios a bit, and a bunch of trial and error, I came up with this absolutely perfect gluten-free sugar cookie recipe, one that I use year round but especially over the winter holidays. I can cut these cookies into any shape and the shape will hold!

How to Make Gluten-Free Sugar Cookies

You might chuckle at how easy it is to make this recipe. So easy!

To make the dough, you cream together butter and sugar for one minute in your standing mixer. Then you add your egg and vanilla until well combined, and then add the 1:1 gluten-free flour.

Mix the dough until all the flour is incorporated.

You’ll then wrap the dough in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least two hours or overnight. Do not skip this step! Refrigeration is key to ensuring these cookies hold their shape.

Tip! Most sugar cookies call for baking powder or baking soda. These ingredients leaven cookies and would interfere with them holding their cut-out shapes. Skip the baking powder and baking soda – and you won’t miss it – trust me!

When you’re ready to make the cookies, roll out the dough to about a one half inch thickness and cut the cookies into the desired shapes.

Next, place your baking sheet (with cut out cookies on it) back in the fridge for another hour. The cold will help the cookies keep their beautiful shape so they look at good as they taste.

Tip! You’ll want to use a well-floured surface to roll out the cookies, however, when you do that, it adds more flour to the mixture and dries out the cookies. Instead of using flour, I use powdered sugar to “flour” my surface. Works like a charm!

Once the gluten-free sugar cookies are chilled, place them in a 350º preheated oven and bake for 13-15 minutes. I suggest cooking them until the bottoms just begin to brown. It’s better to undercook them than overcook them, especially if you’re looking for a chewy, soft-baked texture.

Once the cookies are fully cooled, it’s time to decorate them – the fun part!

To make royal icing, mix egg whites in a standing mixer over medium speed for one minute, then add butter, vanilla and powdered sugar until all ingredients are well incorporated.

Tip! If icing is too stiff, add a little bit of milk; if mixture is too runny, add more powdered sugar.

You’ll then want to portion the icing so you can dye it with different colors. Put a little icing in a variety of bowls and then add desired amount of food coloring to each.

I prefer to use food dye from India Tree because the dyes are vegetable colorants vs. artificial dyes. I personally think no one needs to be eating artificial dye and try to avoid it when possible. You’ll just need to use more food dye than usual when you use the natural stuff.

While I use royal icing to “frost” these cookies because it provides a beautiful, glossy sheen to the cookies, you could also make traditional buttercream frosting, which is fluffier and some might say tastier too.

How Do They Taste?

These gluten-free sugar cookies are surprisingly soft yet still have a slight crunch to them too. (If you slightly undercook them they will be super soft and doughy – so good!!) They’re sweet, tender and perfect for decorating!

Once you add the royal icing, these gluten-free sugar cookies taste even BETTER. I’m not kidding! Let the icing sit atop the cookies for a few hours (or day) before serving them because the taste of the cookies intensifies.

I think it’s because moisture from the icing seeps into the cookies, making them a little sweeter and softer. My mouth is watering thinking about eating these delicious, iced beauties!

I had a lot of fun making these cookies and it was so easy to do with Bob’s Red Mill’s 1-to-1 Gluten-Free Flour Blend.

I know I crush on this flour all the time, but I do it with good reason. Bob’s has yet to let me down. 

I have a feeling this flour will soon become your go-to gluten-free flour blend, and this recipe will be your go-to gluten-free sugar cookie as well. Enjoy!